Are we truthful to our doctors? How has medicine changed over the years?
What is your doctor like? Do they listen? Do you hear what they say?
I was having a long discussion with my elderly friend in the southern US. She grew up with old school medicine and seems to have an old school doctor. Or their healthcare is different in the deep south.
My MIL was old school too. She didn't like to see the doctor and listened to her friends for medical advice quite often. If Silvia had The Gripe and took a particular kind of medicine, then maybe she had The Gripe and should take the same stuff. They traded symptoms and came up with solutions themselves.
Later in her life, she decided that the More She Doctored, the better off she was. Especially if they gave her more pills to fix everything.
I'm guilty of what happens these days. I look things up on the web because we all know that we can cure ourselves on the web.
Some of the older generation never bother to ask the doctor what is going on or perhaps they are afraid of asking. Doctors know everything right? No, they don't. But sometimes getting a doctor to have a real conversation, is like a Mission Impossible Movie.
My friend struggles when seeing her doctors. I don't think she interacts with her PCP. Or perhaps she can't remember what they were talking about. [She has told me that her memory is very bad.] When she tells me about her visit, she complains that no one told her a thing about her ailments. If she gets a new medication, she can't recall why and refuses to take it.
I asked her if she told her PCP about her frequent falls and dizziness. Or about the fact that she felt lonely and depressed?
Um, no, not really.
She said if she told them about her depression then they would call her mental and put it on her record. Therein lies a stigma. Depression = Mental? She is in her late 80's and won't share with her PCP because she feels she would be judged.
If she told the doctor that she has frequent falls they may think she needs help. She said she had dizziness and the doctor ordered blood work. She was angry because dizziness is only dizziness and she knows that her ears need cleaning because her Grandpa had flaky ears. It won't be in her blood work, she needs a specialist.
The last thing I discussed with my elderly friend was that it was okay to tell your doctor the truth, because they were not mind readers and couldn't figure out what might be ailing her if they didn't know she was feeling poorly.
"Do you mean you are truthful with your doctor?"
I was a bit shocked. "Yes ma'am. I do."
I studied for two years to negotiate the ins and outs of doctor visits so that I could code the visits with diagnosis codes for billing. Even I know that humans are incredibly interesting creatures that are still a bit of a mystery for doctors.
And yet here we are trying to find answers.
Sometimes it seems as if you are going 'round and 'round on a merry go 'round with no way off.
Humans are not straightforward in their thinking or their ailments.
Hey, I heard walking was good for you.... and....
I love the doctor clips. I fired a doctor whose nurse grilled me at length, never passed it on, and he'd be angry that we'd talked! I think his own staff kept him out of the loop. But he tried bullying me and I left.
ReplyDeleteI found a much better doctor whose nurse weighs and measures and greets and reassures, and leaves the doctor with the information to work from. And yes, I tell her about any episodes of anything since I was last there. Mostly inconsequential. But if you can't tell your doctor you need either a new attitude or a new doctor!
Absolutely, you are correct in firing a doctor. So far I have been so very lucky to have attentive doctors. My husband had a doctor that I reported and she was fired for ignoring symptoms [long story, she nearly cost hubby his life]. This was 15 years ago.
DeleteMedical care should not be so hard?
My mom was old school and didn't trust doctors. I think that generation was that way; one had to do everything for themselves because of poverty or inaccessibility of doctors. Myself- I don't trust modern doctors much, they tend to be pill pushers and don't even try to find solutions that are other than Big Pharma guidelines. When I got my present doctor when we moved here, I told him he would rarely see me unless I had broken bones or something major. He looked displeased....
ReplyDeleteI do get that. As a kid, going to the doctor was something that happened rarely except for vaccinations or getting stitches. I recall the novelty of when a hospital and ER were built near where I lived. Back in those days, if we had an emergency, we put a call in to the local GP and then drove to his office.
DeleteIn our area we are stock full of alternate methods of doctoring. Our medical building in town hosts a couple of Holistic doctors.
My dr knows I used to come in only for something serious too.
:)
You know my opinion. So I won't repeat it. :)
ReplyDeleteYes, I understand. It is a known fact that women are not treated the same when it comes to doctoring. I hope that will change.
DeleteI will try to post again. Yesterday it would keep saying error. Yes, I think it is very important to give accurate information to your doctor and I have been pretty busy with them this year. My last visit with a new Doctor (mine left the practice) was the best I've ever had. He listened! Lori
ReplyDeleteI got it! The younger generation of doctors I've been seeing,...well, at least here in my town are very open to listening to their patients. This is what I am grateful for.
DeleteAging alone must be so lonely and scary for your friend. There is fear among elderly if they "complain" or share wait ails them, they will lose their freedom and be forced to leave their beloved familiar home etc.
ReplyDeleteThank you for continuing trying to help your friend as best you can from afar.
The hardest part was trying to explain to her that she could qualify for in home help and she won't think of it. I have lived through helping elderly and disabled for a while now and understand that it isn't always so terrible.
DeleteThank you.
We can get print outs of the visit, that gives all the information. They will print it out right after your visit. I watch my Moms my chart for health related info as the Nursing Home PA makes notes about med changes etc. It is a hard situation, sometimes I feel like they are not listening especially as I get older. Hard to help your friend from afar...but I bet she appreciates your input...whether she listens or not is a nother issue.
ReplyDeleteI asked about her printout and she said she gets nothing. Of course, perhaps she didn't ask for it? I don't know.
DeleteBeing able to understand doctor's notes and charts are so important for caring for the elderly -- and ourselves.